BLOOD TRANSFUSIONS:
ARE JWs WINNING?


Part II    [Back to Part 1)

(Investigator 173, 2017 March)


BLOOD STILL NEEDED

Current alternatives to blood transfusion often fail in rapid, massive blood loss as occurs in some maternity cases, accidents and wounds.

Hunt (1993) reported that a man received "400 pints of blood" after a lorry crushed his pelvis and mentions another case when a policeman was stabbed and required 300 pints. The Advertiser reported that a woman received "nearly eight litres of blood" following a "rare complication after she gave birth". (July 19, 2013)

In a study of 1958 JWs who had surgery without blood transfusions Tobian et al (2009) found that "Mortality increases as hemoglobin levels fall." 117 patients had postoperative hemoglobin levels below 6 gram/deciliter of whom 39 died. (Normal levels are 14-17 g/dl for men and 12-15 g/dl for women.)

Many commentators mention "risks of infections" from blood. However, in high-income countries such risks are tiny:
•    HIV: 3/100,000
•    Hepatitis B: 30/100,000
•    Hepatitis C: 20/100,000 (WHO 2016)

It is far riskier to reject blood when surgeons think transfusion necessary.



DIVISIVENESS

In the 1980s the JW Governing Body introduced added monitoring by establishing "Hospital Liaison Committees", and have also advised JWs to give power of attorney to another JW.  Yet many JWs still accepted blood or blood components banned to them. Varela et al (2003) write: "blood transfusions are performed in up to 7% of Jehovah's Witnesses cases…"

Kerry Louderback-Wood (2005) is an American lawyer and former JW whose mother died after rejecting a transfusion. She suggests that the possible misrepresentation of medical risks in JW publications makes the Watchtower Society vulnerable to law suits by relatives of people who died from following the teaching. She argues that constitutional guarantees of freedom of religion do not remove the legal responsibility regarding misrepresenting secular fact.

The Associated Jehovah’s Witnesses for Reform on Blood (AJWRB), founded in 1997 claim to have thousands of supporters in 25 countries including elders, doctors, and members of Hospital Liaison Committees. The founder Lee Elder (a pseudonym) says his grandmother died due to obeying the blood ban.

Further divisiveness is doctrinal revision. In 1961 JWs opposed donation, storage and infusing of both blood and blood fractions:

The Bible is very clear that blood could properly be used only on the altar; otherwise it was to be poured out on the ground. (Lev. 17:11-13) The entire modern medical practice involving the use of blood is objectionable from the Christian standpoint. Therefore the taking of a blood transfusion, or, in lieu of that, the infusing of some blood fraction to sustain one’s life is wrong. (Watchtower 1961 11/1 670)

In the 1970s this total ban began revision by making blood fractions a conscience matter. (Watchtower 1990 6/1 30-31; How Can Blood Save Your Life? 1990, 27)

In 1975 the JW Governing Body banned JW hemophiliacs from receiving clotting factors such as Factor VIII (Awake! 1975 2/22 30) but later permitted clotting factors. (Watchtower 1978 6/15 30)


Transfusions of whole blood (including one's own self-donated blood), red cells, white cells, platelets and plasma are still prohibited. Wikipedia (2016) lists the following as now acceptable:

•    Blood donation for purpose of fractionation of red cells, white cells, platelets or plasma for either allogeneic or autologous transfusion.
•    Hemodilution (when equipment is arranged in a circuit with patients' circulatory systems.
•    Blood salvage — reinfusing blood spilt during surgery.
•    Heart-Lung Machine.
•    Dialysis.
•    Epidural Blood Patch.
•    Plasmapheresis — blood withdrawn, filtered and plasma removed, and returned to the patient.
•    Fractions from red blood cells.
•    Fractions from white blood cells — Interferons and Interleukins.
•    Fractions from platelets — Platelet factor 4.
•    Fractions from blood plasma —  Albumin, Globulins, Cryoprecipitate, Clotting factors including Factor VIII and Factor IX.


ESTIMATED DEATHS

Investigator #12 (1990) cited news reports of four JW deaths from bleeding in South Australia. About 1/700th of JWs worldwide lived in SA; therefore a world total of JW deaths until 1990 was estimated at 700x4 = 2800.

A similar calculation, based on New Zealand with about 1/500th of JWs, and 5 known deaths, is 500x5 = 2500

Such calculations show promise but are questionable because:
•    Sample sizes are too small;
•    Newspapers may not report all JW bleeding-deaths;
•    Probably not all newspaper reports were found;
•    Patients in hospital are there because they are injured or sick and may die whether they receive blood or not.

Singla et al (2001) calculated a maternal death rate of 512 per 100,000 live births among USA JW women. [In most countries the rate for all women is below 70  —  www.indexmundi.com/g/r.aspx?v=2223] Assuming a birth rate of 20 per thousand women per year, and JW females in the 1990s numbering 3,000,000 worldwide, suggests about 300 JW maternal deaths annually in childbirth. Again, the sample is small, based on few actual known deaths.

Most JWs survived surgery, even major surgery. Ott and Cooley (1977) reported cardiovascular surgery in 542 JWs and, "anemia was a contributing factor in 12 deaths, and loss of blood was the direct cause of three deaths." Such positive results, however, may not be as impressive as appears since the surgeons probably "cherry picked" JW patients for their survival potential and bypassed riskier, more-difficult cases.

The total unnecessary JW deaths since 1945 surely number thousands but less than the 250,000 claimed on some websites!


WHO WON?

The conflict with the medical profession originally started when JWs wanted treatment in hospitals but died rather than accept blood.

JWs are right in that blood transfusions were over-used, sometimes transmitted disease, and have other risks associated with them. (Nowak 2008)  However, a small risk of disease is tolerable compared to death when bleeding is severe.
 
In 1961 the JW blood ban included blood fractions. JWs lost that debate when they began to accept blood fractions. This contradicted their teaching that even collection and storage of blood is unbiblical. JWs also sometimes removed children from hospital and hid them to prevent transfusions but that practice apparently stopped.

Investigator #8 suggested the JW Governing Body would retain their blood ban despite the dubious theology behind it in the hope that new technology will reduce the need for transfusions. JWs have endured numerous revisions to their "Bible truth" (i.e. their doctrines), including other medical conflicts and false dates for Armageddon, and might not cope well if it's also admitted that thousands died needlessly.

Technology indeed "came to the rescue" including hyperbaric oxygen therapy, blood fractions, "blood management", laser surgery, faster surgery times, artificial blood, and in future possibly stem cells:

Blood donations may become a thing of the past due to advances in stem cell technology... The Daily Telegraph says that a new way has been discovered of growing “potentially unlimited supplies of blood in the lab”… (Harborough Mail, 19 August, 2008)

Advances in technology, however, require the work of highly trained graduates whereas JW theology discourages education beyond high-school:

If you are a young person, you also need to face the fact that you will never grow old in this present system of things. Why not?  Because all the evidence in fulfillment of Bible prophecy indicates that this corrupt system is due to end in a few years. Of the generation that observed the beginning of the "last days" in 1914, Jesus foretold: "This generation will by no means pass away until all these things occur."—Matt. 24:34.

Therefore, as a young person, you will never fulfill any career that this system offers. If you are in high school and thinking about a college education, it means at least four, perhaps six or eight more years to graduate into a specialized career. But where will this system of things be by that time? It will be well on the way toward its finish, if not actually gone! (Awake! 1969 May 22, page 15)

The advanced education criticized and discouraged by JWs has saved thousands of their lives! Ironic!

The main losers are the JWs who died unnecessarily believing they won't stay dead for long because Armageddon would come in "the twentieth century".

But on the propaganda front JWs are winners. The conflict with courts, hospitals and critics, along with JWs being useful as volunteers in medical research, gained the sect much free publicity.


REFERENCES:

Alexi-Meskishvili V., Stiller B, Koster A., Böttcher W., Hübler M., Photiadis J., Lange P.E., Hetzer R. Correction of congenital heart defects in Jehovah's Witness children, The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, June 2004, 52(3):141-146

Angouras, D.C. 11 February, 2013
http://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/1570244

Bakdash, S., Yazer, M.H. What every physician should know about transfusion reactions, Canadian Medical Association Journal, July 17, 2007, 177(2): 141–147

Busch, M.P., Kleinman, S.H., Nemo, G.J. Current and Emerging Infectious Risks of Blood Transfusions, JAMA, February 26, 2003, 289(8), 961

Carson, J.L., Poses, R.M., Spence, R.K., Bonavita, G. Severity of anaemia and operative mortality and morbidity, Lancet, 1988, April 2, 727-729
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2895260

Carson, V. 18 April, 2013
 www.dailytelegraph.com.au
 
Carter, C. 2014 Mail Online, 8 December, 2014
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2865363

Cooley, D.A. Open Heart Surgery in Jehovah's Witnesses, American Journal of Cardiology, June 1964, 13:779-781

Corderoy, A. Pregnant Jehovah's Witness' decision to refuse treatment 'harrowing' for hospital staff after mother and baby die
Sydney Morning Herald, 6 April, 2015

Currie J., Hogg M., Patel N., Madgwick K., Yoong W. Management of women who decline blood and blood products in pregnancy, The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist, 2010, 12:13–20

Davis, N. Better Than Blood? Popular Science, November 2006, 89-94

Department of Health. Report on Confidential Enquiries into Maternal Deaths in the United Kingdom 1994–1996. Why Mothers Die. London. The Stationery Office, 1998, 1-275.

Detry O. et al 2005 Liver transplantation in Jehovah's witnesses, Transplant International, August 2005, 18(8), 929–936

Dictionary of Jehovah's Witnesses
http://ed5015.tripod.com/jwdictionary/CONTENTS.html

Doyle, D.J. Blood Transfusions and the Jehovah's Witness Patient, American Journal of Surgery, September-October 2002, 9(5), 417-424
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12237734

Geddes, L. Bags of blood and not a donor in sight, New Scientist, 12 November 2011, 8-9

Gonzalez, E.R. The saga of 'artificial blood', JAMA, February 22/29, 1980, 243(8), 719-724

Henderson, M. 10 August, 2012
www.theaustralian.com.au/news/latest-news/.../story-fn3dxiwe-1226447338350

House, T. Transplant History
liverfoundation.org.au/display/index/about-transplant

Hunt, L. The Independent Online, 25 May 1993
www.independent.co.uk/news/accident-victim-gets-400-pints-of-blood-transfusion-service-appeals-for-donors-2324986

Hyslop, L. Ex-Jehovah's Witness bled to death after surgery, Marlborough Express, 20 October, 2014
 
International Anesthesia Research Society
www.openanesthesia.org/jehovahs_witness_patients/

Investigator Magazine 1989 #8; 1990 #12

Jabbour, N. (editor) 2005 Transfusion Free Medicine and Surgery, Blackwell

Khadra, M., Rigby, C., Warren, P., Leighton, N., Johanson, R. 2002 A criterion audit of women's awareness of blood transfusion in pregnancy
http://bmcpregnancychildbirth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1471-2393-2-7

Kidson-Gerber, G., Kerridge, I., Farmer, S., Stewart, C.L., Savoia, H., Challis, D. Caring for pregnant women for whom transfusion is not an option... Australian and New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, April 2016, Volume 56(2), 127–136
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/ajo.12420/full

Kitchens, C.S. Are transfusions overrated? Surgical outcome of Jehovah's Witnesses, The American Journal of Medicine, February 1993, 94:117-119

Kumari, N. and R. Surgical management in treatment of Jehovah's witness in trauma surgery in Indian subcontinent, Journal of Emergencies, Trauma, and Shock, July-September 2014, 7(3), 215-221
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4126123

Langone, J. New Methods for Saving Blood, Time, December 5, 1988

Lauder, S. Synthetic blood saves a life
www.abc.au/worldtoday/content/2011/s3208571.htm

Lee, E.S., Kim, M.J., Park, B.R., Kim, J.S.,  Choi, G.Y., Lee, J.J., Lee, I.S. Avoiding unnecessary blood transfusions in women with profound anaemia, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 5 June, 2015, 55 (3), 262–267
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/ajo.12329/full

Louderback-Wood, K. 2005 Jehovah's Witnesses, Blood Transfusions, and the Tort of Misrepresentation, Journal of Church and State, December 13, 2005

Marinakis, S., Van der Linden, P., Tortora, R., Massaut, J., Pierrakos, C., Wauthy, P. 2016 Outcomes from cardiac surgery in Jehovah’s witness patients: experience over twenty-one years, Journal of Cardiothoracic Surgery, 4 April, 2016, 11:67
https://cardiothoracicsurgery.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s13019-016-0455-6

Massiah, N., Athimulam, S., Loo, C., Okolo, S., Yoong, W. Obstetric care of Jehovah's Witnesses: a 14-year observational study, Archives of Gynecology and Obstetrics, October 2007, 276(4):339-343

Michael, S. & Beers, L. Daily Mail, 7 April, 2015
www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3027599

Muramoto, O. Bioethics of the refusal of Blood by Jehovah's Witnesses: Part 1, Journal of Medical Ethics 1998, 24:223-230; Part 2, 24:295-301
jme.bmj.com/content/24/4/223.full.pdf
jmebeta.bmj.com/content/medethics/24/5/295.full.pdf

Nowak, R. Blood doesn't always save lives, New Scientist, 26 April, 2008, 8-9

Oakes, D. Treating patients like Jehovah's Witnesses could save lives... The Age, 28 May, 2007


Ostrow, N. Jehovah's Witnesses recover best from surgery, despite refusing blood, Sydney Morning Herald, 4 July, 2012

Ott, D.A.; Cooley, D.A. Cardiovascular Surgery in Jehovah's Witnesses Report of 542 Operations Without Blood Transfusions, JAMA, 1977, 238(12), 1256-1258

Pattakos, G., Koch, C.G., Brizzio, M.E. et al, Outcome of Patients Who Refuse Transfusion After Cardiac Surgery, Archives of Internal Medicine, 2012, 172(15), 1154-1160

Perrotta P.L., Snyder, E.L. Non-infectious complications of transfusion therapy, Blood Reviews, June 2001, 15(2):69-83
www.bloodreviews.com/article/S0268-960X(01)90151-1

Raftery, I. 2015
http://kuow.org/post/when-14-year-old-chooses-die-because-religion-can-anyone-stop-him

Roberts, L. 18 May, 2010
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/7734480/Teenage-Jehovahs-Witness-refuses-blood-transfusion-and-dies.html

Sack, K. 24 February, 2013
Bloodless Lung Transplants Offer Hint at Surgery's Future
www.nytimes.com/2013/02/25/us/bloodless-lung-transplants-for-jehovahs-witnesses.html

Saltus, R. Medical dilemma: Patients dying in artificial blood experiment, S.F. Sunday Examiner & Chronicle, October 3, 1982, A17

Saunders, C. & Saxon, M. 20 May, 2014 How two Jehovah’s Witnesses were paid millions to restrict WA blood transfusions
 www.perthnow.com/

Schaffer, A. How Jehovah’s Witnesses Are Changing Medicine, The New Yorker, August 12, 2015

Schaffer, A. The Ethics of Bloodless Medicine
www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-ethics-of-bloodless-medicine/

Shafer, W. Adverse Effects of Transfusions, Southern Medical Journal, April 1976, Volume 69(4), 476-478

Singla, A.K., Lapinski, R.H., Berkowitz, R.L., Saphier, C.J. Are women who are Jehovah's Witnesses at risk of maternal death? American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, October 2001, 185(4), 893–895

Stamou, S.C., White, T., Barnett, S., Boyce, S.W., Corso, P.J., Lefrak, E.A. Comparisons of cardiac surgery outcomes in Jehovah's versus Non-Jehovah's Witnesses, American Journal of Cardiology, 1 November, 2006, 98(9), 1223-1225
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17056333

Stein, J.I., Gombotz, H., Rigler, B., Metzler, H., Suppan, C., Beitzke, A. Open heart surgery in children of Jehovah's witnesses: Extreme hemodilution on cardiopulmonary bypass, Pediatric Cardiology, 1991, 12(3), 170-174
http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF02238525

The Australian, 10 November, 2011, Blood transfusion would likely have saved Jehova's Witness patient

Tobian, A.A., Ness, P.M., Noveck, H., Carson, J.L. Time course and etiology in patients with severe anemia, Transfusion, July 2009, 49(7), 1395-1399

Van Wolfswinkel M.E., Zwart J.J., Schutte J.M. et al. Maternal mortality and serious maternal morbidity in Jehovah's witnesses in the Netherlands. BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 2009, Volume 116(8), 1103–1110
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1471-0528.2009.02191.x/full

Varela, J.E., Gomez-Marin, O., Fleming, L.E., Cohn, S.M. The Risk of Death for Jehovah's Witnesses after Major Trauma, The Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical Care, May 2003, 54(5), 967-972
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov.pubmed/12777911

Venter, Z.  17 June, 2014
www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/kwazulu-natal/jehovahs-witness-girl-saved-by-court-1700022.htm


Walker R.H.T Transfusion risks, American Journal of Clinical Pathology, 1987, 88: 374-378

WHO 2016 Fact Sheet  www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs279/en/

Wittmann, P.H. and F.W. Total Hip Replacement Surgery Without Blood Transfusion, British Journal of Anaesthesia, 1992, 68(3), 306-307
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1547056

Wooding, N. Costs incurred by one severely ill Jehovah's Witness could run one unit in Africa for one year. British Medical Journal, 1999, 27 March, 318:873

Woolley, S. Children of Jehovah’s Witnesses and adolescent Jehovah’s Witnesses: what are their rights? Archives of Disease in Children, 2005, 90:715–719

Zaorski, J.R., Hallman, G.L.; Cooley, D.A. Open Heart Surgery for Acquired Heart Disease in Jehovah's Witnesses, The American Journal of Cardiology, February 1972, Volume 29, 186-189

http://europepmc.org/abstract/med/1998423

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_transfusion.htm

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2782596

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8191563

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8874456

www.chron.com/news/houston-texas/article/Houston-surgeons-perform-transplants-without-3432497.php

www.hopkinsmedicine.org/bloodless_medicine_surgery/

www.news-medical.net/news/20110705/First-bloodless-heart-transplant-on-6-year-old-boy-performed-at-Nationwide-Childrens-Hospital.aspx

www.redcrossblood.org/learn-about-blood/blood-facts-and-statistics

www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/06/blood-management-bloodless-medicine-transfusions/395054/


Get accurate knowledge about JWs on this website:

http://users.adam.com.au/bstett/

http://ed5015.tripod.com/