History
Colon therapy or colonic irrigation was practised by the ancient
Egyptians who erroneously associated feces with decay, and decay with
death, concluding that all diseases began in the colon.
Hippocrates and Galen, ancient Greek physicians, both mentioned the use
of enemas and the Romans, with their preoccupation for baths, used
enemas for internal cleansing.
In the 19th. century, the idea that poisons from putrifying intestinal
bacteria entered the body through the gut wall led to the
popularisation of the intestinal toxicity theory. This
"autointoxication" theory was popular around the turn of the century
but was abandoned by the scientific community during the 1930s.
Theory
Down through the years, various "roughages" — bran, apples and yoghurt
among them, have been advocated to achieve rapid elimination of waste.
To these has been added colonic irrigation through the use of enemas.
Practice
A procedure in which liquids, a few litres at a time, are infused
through a tube into the colon via the rectum, to wash away and remove
the contents.
Other liquids used include coffee, herbs and enzymes. Up to eighty
litres, pumped by machine or gravity fed, may be involved in a "high
colonic" to achieve its purpose.
Assessment
Like the ancient Egyptians, today's proponents claim that "all disease
and death begins in the colon"; that colonies "detoxify" the body, and
that regular "cleansing" is essential to maintain one's health. None of
these claims are true.
"Detoxification" is based on the notion that, as a result of intestinal
stasis, intestinal contents putrefy and toxins are formed and absorbed
which causes chronic poisoning of the body. No such "toxins" have ever
been found, and careful observations have shown that individuals in
good health can vary greatly in bowel habits. Proponents may also
suggest that fecal material collects on the lining of the intestine and
causes trouble unless removed by laxatives, colonic irrigation, special
diets, and/or various herbs or food supplements that "cleanse" the
body.
The falsity of this notion is obvious to doctors who perform intestinal
surgery or peer within the large intestine with a diagnostic
instrument. Fecal material does not adhere to the intestinal lining.
While today we understand the importance of dietary fibre, medical
scientists know that this has nothing to do with intestinal toxicity.
Colonic irrigation is simply a health fetish appealing to those who,
for one reason or another, believe themselves to be "unclean" or
"impure".
There are also some health hazards associated with this type of
therapy. They include illness and death by contamination of colonics
equipment (Istre 1982); death by electrolyte depletion (Eisele, 1980),
(Ballantine, 1981), and the possibility that colonic apparatus can
perforate the intestinal wall leading to septicemia.
Colonic irrigation through the use of enemas or water is a dangerous
pseudo-medicinal therapy.
Bibliography:
Eisele. 1980. Deaths Related to Coffee Enemas. JAMA. 244:1608-9.
Franklin. 1981. Questions and Answers: colonic irrigation. JAMA.246:2869.
Kastner, Mark and Burroughs, Hugh. 1993. Alternative Healing. Halcyon
Publishing, La Mesa, California.
Kizer. 1985. The case against colonic irrigation. California Morbidity #38. September
27.